Wednesday, June 5, 2024

Emerald vs. Aquamarine: Which is More Expensive?

Introduction to Emeralds and Aquamarines

Emeralds and aquamarines are two of the most cherished gemstones, known for their captivating beauty and unique characteristics. Both belong to the beryl family of minerals but differ significantly in color, rarity, and value. Emeralds are renowned for their deep green hues, while aquamarines are celebrated for their serene blue tones. This article delves into the intricate details of both gemstones, examining their color and appearance, rarity and origin, quality factors, and price comparison. By the end of this comprehensive analysis, readers will have a clear understanding of which gemstone typically commands a higher price and why.


Color and Appearance

Emeralds: Emeralds are prized for their rich, vibrant green color, which ranges from bluish-green to pure green with intense saturation. The finest emeralds exhibit a deep green hue that is not too dark, as overly dark stones can appear blackish and less desirable. The color of an emerald is a result of trace amounts of chromium, vanadium, or iron within the mineral. Emeralds often contain inclusions, which are natural imperfections formed during the gem’s creation. These inclusions, sometimes referred to as the “jardin” (French for garden), can give emeralds a unique character but can also impact their clarity and value.


Aquamarines: In contrast, aquamarines are known for their clear, ocean-like blue color, which can range from a pale, almost colorless blue to a deep, vibrant blue. The color of aquamarine is due to the presence of iron within the beryl structure. Unlike emeralds, aquamarines are typically more transparent and have fewer inclusions, giving them a clearer and cleaner appearance. The most valuable aquamarines are those with a rich, intense blue color, often referred to as “Santa Maria” blue, named after the famed Brazilian mine.

Rarity and Origin

Emeralds: Emeralds are significantly rarer than aquamarines, which contributes to their higher market value. The finest emeralds are predominantly sourced from Colombia, specifically from the Muzo, Coscuez, and Chivor mines, which are known for producing high-quality stones with exceptional color. Other notable sources include Zambia, Brazil, and Zimbabwe. The rarity of high-quality emeralds is compounded by the fact that they are more prone to inclusions and fractures, making large, flawless emeralds exceedingly scarce.

Aquamarines: While aquamarines are also a precious gemstone, they are generally more abundant than emeralds. Major sources of aquamarine include Brazil, Nigeria, Madagascar, Mozambique, and Pakistan. Brazil, in particular, is renowned for producing some of the finest and largest aquamarine specimens. The relative abundance of aquamarine and its typically cleaner appearance means that high-quality stones are more readily available compared to emeralds.

Quality Factors

Emeralds: The value of an emerald is determined by several key quality factors: color, clarity, cut, and carat weight. Of these, color is the most crucial. The finest emeralds possess a vivid, well-balanced green color. Clarity is also important, but because inclusions are common in emeralds, they are often more tolerated than in other gemstones. However, too many inclusions or those that significantly impact transparency can reduce an emerald’s value. The cut of an emerald is designed to maximize its color and minimize the appearance of inclusions. Carat weight also plays a significant role; larger emeralds with good color and clarity are exceptionally rare and command high prices.

Aquamarines: For aquamarines, the primary quality factors are color, clarity, cut, and carat weight. The most valuable aquamarines are those with a deep, vivid blue color. Clarity is a critical factor since aquamarines are typically eye-clean, meaning they have no visible inclusions. The cut of an aquamarine can significantly affect its appearance and value, with well-cut stones displaying excellent brilliance. Larger aquamarines are more common than larger emeralds, but fine specimens still command premium prices.

Price Comparison

When comparing the prices of emeralds and aquamarines, several factors must be considered, including color, clarity, size, and overall quality.

Emeralds: Due to their rarity and the demand for high-quality stones, emeralds are generally more expensive than aquamarines. Fine-quality emeralds can range from $500 to $5,000 per carat, with exceptional stones fetching even higher prices. For example, an emerald with a deep green color, good clarity, and a significant carat weight can command prices upwards of $10,000 per carat. Historical and cultural significance also play a role in the high valuation of emeralds, with famous emeralds often setting records at auctions.

Aquamarines: Aquamarines, while still valuable, tend to be more affordable than emeralds. Fine-quality aquamarines typically range from $100 to $1,000 per carat, with the most exceptional stones reaching up to $1,500 or more per carat. The price of aquamarines can vary depending on the depth of color, with the deepest blue stones being the most prized. However, due to their relative abundance and the lower incidence of inclusions, aquamarines generally cost less than emeralds of comparable quality and size.

Specific Examples


The Rockefeller Emerald: This 18.04-carat emerald was sold at auction for $5.5 million, translating to approximately $305,000 per carat. Its extraordinary color, clarity, and historical provenance contributed to its high value.

The Bahia Emerald: One of the largest emeralds ever found, the Bahia Emerald weighs an astonishing 341 kg (752 lbs). While its sheer size makes it invaluable, its price per carat would be lower due to its industrial-grade quality and extensive inclusions.


The Dom Pedro Aquamarine: This stunning gemstone, weighing 10,363 carats, is the largest cut aquamarine in the world. Its value is enhanced by its flawless clarity and deep blue color, though individual aquamarine carats generally cost less than emeralds.

A Fine Santa Maria Aquamarine: A 10-carat Santa Maria aquamarine, known for its deep blue hue, can fetch prices up to $15,000, or $1,500 per carat, showcasing the premium attached to top-quality stones.


In the realm of precious gemstones, both emeralds and aquamarines hold significant allure and value. However, emeralds generally command higher prices due to their rarity, distinctive color, and the challenges associated with finding high-quality specimens. The vivid green of an emerald, often accompanied by its characteristic inclusions, makes it a unique and highly sought-after gemstone. On the other hand, aquamarines, with their serene blue tones and greater availability, offer a more affordable yet equally captivating alternative for gemstone enthusiasts.

Ultimately, the choice between an emerald and an aquamarine comes down to personal preference and budget. Collectors and connoisseurs may lean towards the historical prestige and rarity of emeralds, while those seeking a beautiful, clear, and vibrant gemstone at a more accessible price point might prefer aquamarines. Both gemstones, with their unique qualities and beauty, continue to captivate and inspire, making them cherished additions to any jewelry collection.

Related topics:

Alice is a seasoned jewelry designer renowned for her exquisite creations that seamlessly blend artistry with elegance. With a passion for craftsmanship and an unwavering commitment to quality, Alice has established herself as a distinguished figure in the world of fine jewelry. Drawing inspiration from diverse cultures and artistic movements, Alice brings a unique perspective to her designs, creating pieces that transcend mere accessories to become timeless works of art. Her meticulous attention to detail and insistence on using only the finest materials ensure that each creation reflects not only her artistic vision but also a commitment to unparalleled craftsmanship. Having honed her skills through years of dedicated practice and a keen understanding of evolving trends, Alice is adept at translating her clients' desires into bespoke, one-of-a-kind pieces. Her portfolio encompasses a range of styles, from classic and timeless to avant-garde and contemporary, showcasing her versatility and ability to cater to a diverse clientele.

Related Articles

Latest Articles